Emergent Behavior

Emergent behavior is behavior of a system that does not depend on its individual parts, but on their relationships to one another. Thus emergent behavior cannot be predicted by examination of a system's individual parts. It can only be predicted, managed, or controlled by understanding the parts and their relationships. Emergent behavior is also known as emergence, emergent property, or “the whole is greater than the sum of the parts.” How emergent behavior works is illustrated by this diagram: 1

How Life Emerges from Parts in a Eukaryote Cell

All systems are composed of individual parts. Something arranges the parts into a structure. The structure then determines the behavior of the system. System analysis is thus a matter of identifying the relevant structure of the system and its most important parts.

The key insight of the concept of emergent behavior is it's the arrangement of the parts, and not the parts themselves, that makes the big difference. The chemicals in the human body can be purchased for a few dollars. Buying them and mixing them up in a bucket, or even spending a hundred years to arrange them, would not create a person. That's why it's structure that makes all the diffference.

Examples of parts are atoms, the parts in a machine, people, and nations. Each of these is a system because it's made up of smaller parts. Each of these parts is in turn a part in a larger system.

Examples of structure are the social contract people enter into to form a government, the molecular structure of a chemical compound like carbon dioxide, and the way your cells are organized into organs, which are then organized into your body.

Examples of emergent behavior are life, the way the sun can serve as an energy source for billions of years, the dysfunctionality of a gang, and our favorite, the environmental sustainability problem.

Why this is important

The concept of emergent behavior is hugely important to solving the sustainability problem because it's emergent behavior that's the problem to solve. But when you examine how scholars, activists, politicians, and environmental organizations are analyzing the sustainability problem as a whole, you will discover they are not studying the relevant structure of the system as a whole. They are mostly studying individual parts or subsystems that are not that crucial to resolving the root causes. This is a grave error, pun intended.

The heart of the concept of systems thinking is that the behavior of a system is an emergent property of its structure, not its parts. Problem symptoms are emergent behaviors. Each symptom can be traced to particular aspects of the structure. It follows that if you don't know the structure of a complex social system problem, then you will be unable to solve the problem except by trial and error. For difficult problems this is impossible.

This leads to one of our key principles:

Key Principle

If you don't understand the structure of a difficult problem,
then you can't solve the problem.

This applies to all difficult complex system problems. The implications (as well as the opportunity) for the environmental movement are profound.

(1) The image at the top of this page was prepared by Thwink.org from this image of a cell in the Wikipedia entry for a biological cell.

Browse the Glossary
Previous Next
RELATED INFORMATION
What Lies at the Core of Solving Difficult Social Problems?

Key Principle

The behavior of a system emerges from the structure of its parts.

This principle is the key to solving difficult social problems. From it arise all the other principles at Thwink.org.

The principle that "The only way to solve a difficult problem is to resolve its root causes" really says that the only reliable way to change the behavior of a system is to understand its structure so well that a small number of changes to the structure will solve the problem. These changes are to the parts and their connections that are causing the undesired emergent behavior. These parts and connections are the root causes of the problem.

This is also the foundational principle of systems thinking. Thus the key to understanding systems thinking is understanding the phenomenon of emergent behavior.

Our Most Popular Pages

These average 9 minutes. They give a quick introduction to the Dueling Loops model and how it explains the tremendous change resistance to solving the sustainability problem.

The most eye-opening article on the site since it was written in December 2005. More people have contacted us about this easy to read paper and the related Dueling Loops videos than anything else on the site.

Why are large for-profit corporations so dominant? What are the side effects? What's the root cause of corporate dominance? What's a solution that would work?

The answers are all here.

Do you every wonder why the sustainability problem is so impossibly hard to solve? It's because of the phenomenon of change resistance. The system itself, and not just individual social agents, is strongly resisting change. Why this is so, its root causes, and several potential solutions are presented.

The most astonishing short read (7 pages) on the site, if you've never heard about it. The memo was written in 1971.